Club Sawtooth

Grand Avenue Field Notes

Fishing near Arco, Idaho: tailwater, reservoir and mountain streams

Arco sits at the bottom of a valley that drains a large slice of the Lost River Range, which is why the fishing here is better than the high desert look suggests. Three kinds of water are within an hour: the Big Lost River below Mackay Reservoir, the reservoir itself, and Forest Service creeks and lakes up the canyons behind Mackay and Arco. Each behaves differently and each has its own rules, so the plan starts with which water you are actually going to. This guide covers the access, the seasons and the licence paperwork that decide whether the trip works.

Jump to trip essentials
Region
Lost River Valley, Idaho
Season
Fishing seasons and harvest rules vary by water; ice fishing only when conditions are safe
Category
Fishing
Editorial illustration of fly fishing on a mountain stream and shore fishing at a reservoir near Arco
Editorial illustration, not a photograph of a specific access site: the Big Lost River and Mackay Reservoir offer different fishing conditions.Illustration · not a photograph.

Before you go

  • Anglers age 14 and older generally need a valid Idaho fishing license; buy it from Idaho Fish and Game or an authorized vendor, not an unverified third-party site.
  • Mackay Reservoir covers about 1,139 acres and holds stocked rainbow trout plus a self-sustaining kokanee population.
  • Big Lost River fishing below the reservoir depends on releases and irrigation withdrawals, so flow can change without notice.
  • The Lost River Ranger District manages roughly 817,000 acres across the Big Lost, Little Lost and part of the Wood River drainages.
  • The 2025–2027 Big Lost River and tributaries rules require catch-and-release for trout (except brook trout) from December 1 through the Friday before Memorial Day weekend. The listed trout limit changes on Saturday; whitefish remain catch-and-release year-round. Check current corrections before fishing.

Named waters, not a single pin

Arco is the base; the nearest waters are the Big Lost River and Mackay Reservoir, 20 to 25 miles north.

View on OpenStreetMap

The Big Lost River below Mackay Reservoir

The Big Lost River runs downstream from Mackay Reservoir south toward Arco before parts of the lower channel sink into the Snake River Plain. Below the dam, releases and irrigation shape the fishing; Idaho Fish and Game specifically warns that the river is intermittently dewatered downstream of the Blaine Diversion near Rothwell Access. Do not assume the lower river is a reliable year-round fishery. The corridor mixes public parcels, private ranch land and documented access sites, so a continuous blue line on a map is not a continuous public walk.

What decides the trip on any given week is water. Releases, irrigation withdrawals and reservoir level all move the flow, and a low tailwater in late August means trout holding in the few deep runs that still have current. Fish the seams and the undercut banks, keep moving, and stop when the water turns warm and shallow rather than pushing on. Fly anglers work nymphs and leeches below the surface and streamers when the reservoir is releasing hard; dry-fly windows exist but they are brief.

Do not fish from the dam or any other restricted structure unless official access explicitly permits it. That is a safety rule before it is a legal one.

For Big Lost River fly fishing, carry a range of mayfly, caddis and terrestrial dries, nymphs and small streamers rather than planning around a fixed hatch date. A dry-dropper can cover shallow riffles; nymphs or streamers can work deeper runs when flows and regulations allow. Check actual water temperature and handle released fish quickly in warm weather. The upper river, North and East Forks and Copper Basin are farther and more remote than the Mackay tailwater; bring supplies before driving beyond Mackay.

The BLM Big Lost River Access Trail near Mackay is a signed nonmotorized access option. Stay on the designated trail beside private land; do not assume a bridge, road crossing or mapped riverbank grants permission to park or enter. Confirm current access and flows with the Fishing Planner before committing to a reach.

The Idaho Fishing Planner lists a seasonal Big Lost River and tributaries exception in the 2025–2027 rules: trout other than brook trout are catch-and-release from December 1 through the Friday before Memorial Day weekend, and whitefish are catch-and-release all year. From Saturday of Memorial Day weekend through November 30 the listed trout limit changes, but confirm the exact reach, current corrections and other special rules before keeping a fish.

Mackay Reservoir

Mackay Reservoir is the family fishing water of the valley, and Idaho Fish and Game lists it as both a recommended and a family fishing option. It covers roughly 1,139 acres and supports stocked rainbow trout alongside a kokanee run that produces high catch rates in many years. Shore fishing works from the developed shoreline and from suitable bank areas; a boat opens the deeper water where the kokanee hold in summer.

There is a developed BLM campground and day-use area with a boat ramp and dock, toilets and seasonal services, which makes this the easiest fishing option for a group with children or for anyone who wants a toilet and a ramp rather than a bushwhack. Fees, water availability and boat-access conditions change with the season, so confirm them before driving. There is a modest lesson in the reservoir itself: high-desert water can build a nasty chop when the afternoon wind comes up across an open basin, even after a glass-calm morning. A personal flotation device for everyone on a boat is not optional equipment here.

Mountain streams and the Copper Basin country

Up the canyons beyond Mackay, small Forest Service streams, the North and East Forks and Copper Basin offer a different trip from the reservoir: longer drives, variable roads and water levels, and no guarantee of fish in a particular tributary. Idaho Fish and Game documents brook, rainbow and cutthroat trout and mountain whitefish in the broader Big Lost drainage; a historical survey of one creek is not evidence of current fish numbers in another. Check the exact water in the Fishing Planner and take everything needed before leaving Mackay.

Wildhorse Canyon is the practical version of that trip. Wildhorse Campground, with 13 campsites, seasonal hand-pump water and accessible vault toilets, sits near the head of the canyon with Boulder Creek Lake and the Waterfall Trail close by, and the Forest Service lists stream, lake and pond fishing in the area. Road and campground opening dates are published as approximate and depend on snow and road conditions.

A caution that applies to the whole upper watershed: do not assume the headwater network is open. Copper Basin in particular mixes public-land routes, active grazing, private holdings and access that varies reach by reach. A public fishing-access point is also just that, an access point, not permission to walk the whole drainage.

Licence, rules and the things that end a trip

Anglers age 14 and older need an Idaho fishing license. Buy through Idaho Fish and Game or an authorized vendor and select the correct resident or nonresident option. Read the current rules and corrections for the exact water, including the Big Lost River seasonal catch-and-release exception; do not assume the same trout limit applies at the reservoir and on every tributary.

The other four things that end trips around here, in rough order of how often they happen: irrigation dropping the tailwater, a mountain road still closed under snow in June, a warm spell putting trout down in a shallow river, and winter ice whose safety varies by location and by day on the same reservoir. None of these are visible from Arco. All of them are answerable by a phone call to the land manager or a look at the current regulation before you load the car.

  • Water temperature: even a tailwater can warm in summer. Carry a thermometer, handle fish gently and stop fishing if conditions stress them.
  • Access: verify the specific put-in and take-out rather than assuming the bank is public.
  • Ice: no general date is safe. Ask locally about current thickness before walking out.

Finishing the day in Arco

Club Sawtooth is not a fishing outfitter, a license vendor, a shuttle service or a boat storage facility. It is where the day ends: 156 W Grand Ave, open daily from 2pm, with room to spread out tackle that got tangled and a jukebox for the argument about which run produced the fish. Beer and wine are sold to go under the current license, and Idaho law prohibits passengers and drivers in an ordinary motor vehicle on a public highway from drinking or possessing an open container, so it travels home sealed and gets opened at the campsite or in town.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a fishing license in Idaho, and at what age?

Idaho guidance says anglers age 14 and older generally need a valid Idaho fishing license, with different products for residents, nonresidents and youth. Buy from Idaho Fish and Game or an authorized vendor and check the current regulation for the specific water.

Can I fly fish near Arco?

Yes. Rainbow trout in the Big Lost below Mackay Reservoir and in Mackay Reservoir itself take nymphs, leeches, streamers and seasonal dry flies from suitable shore areas or a boat. Mountain creeks up the canyons hold smaller brook trout.

Is there fishing right in Arco?

Not in town. The nearest real fishing is the Big Lost River and Mackay Reservoir, roughly 20 to 25 miles north, or Forest Service water in the canyons beyond. Plan on a drive and carry water and sun protection.

Can Club Sawtooth arrange guides, boats or licenses?

No. Club Sawtooth is the after-adventure stop in Arco. Licenses, tackle, guides, boats and land access are arranged independently through Idaho Fish and Game and licensed outfitters.

Sources and updates

Check current access, hours and conditions before setting out.